Experts recommend that parents and caregivers prioritize “high quality” content during the time their children spend with screens. However, with more digital platforms, apps, content, games, and media available than ever before, what should parents and caregivers look for when evaluating whether content is high quality? Experts suggest looking for the following characteristics below in platforms, devices, and/or content.

Look for a Story that Supports Learning

When choosing media for your child, one of the first indicators of the content’s quality is its narrative. The highest quality media doesn’t isolate learning, but weaves it into a meaningful story or activity. (Any product can be advertised as educational even if there is little evidence to support this.)

Watch for how new ideas or elements are introduced into the narrative. Do they add to the story or distract from it? Are there pauses for reflection and language building? These details help children learn better.

Prioritize Meaningful Engagement

Bright colors, flashy visuals, fast pacing, and exciting features keep children entertained, but don’t necessarily help them develop meaningful skills. Research suggests that these intense sensory experiences distract from the narrative, making it harder for children to process information and think critically about it. For younger children, and for some children with neurodevelopmental differences, such content can also make it more difficult to transition away from screens.

When choosing content, ask yourself whether engagement features support your child’s well-being and learning. Do they encourage answering questions, solving problems, or making choices that affect the story? Such interactivity can deepen a child’s understanding of a subject.

Be Mindful of Advertising

High-quality children’s media contains few, if any, ads. Because today’s marketing is embedded directly into children’s content, it can be difficult to recognize and think critically about promoted content. Be mindful of content focused on promoting products and brands, or encouraging purchases.

Consider Your Values and Your Specific Child

Children learn from the behaviors, relationships, and values they see modeled. Research shows that screen content featuring kindness, cooperation, empathy, and problem-solving can encourage children to adopt those behaviors in real life. In turn, media that frequently depicts aggression, cruelty, or disrespect may normalize those behaviors.

When evaluating media, consider whether the characters and situations reflect the values you want your child to learn. Age ratings can be a useful starting point, but they do not always align with your family’s specific priorities.

When in doubt, trust your instincts. Every child responds differently to media and you know your child best. Pay attention to how your child behaves during and after watching or playing with a device. Do they seem calm, curious, and engaged, or overstimulated and irritable? Your child’s response is one of the most valuable indicators of whether a particular piece of content is a good fit.

If allowing preschool-aged children access to the world of digital apps, make sure to choose higher-quality ones instead of ones that just look fun or engaging. Also note that “just because an app costs money doesn’t mean it’s a better app than a free one,” says Roberta Golinkoff, PhD, Unidel H. Rodney Sharp Chair and Professor, School of Education, University of Delaware.

How do you evaluate a “good quality” app? Look for these qualities:

    • Active – not passive
    • Engaging – not distracting
    • Meaningful to the child – not disjointing and relevant to the child’s life and level of understanding
    • Iterative – changes each time a child interacts with it beyond just getting a grade or a hand clapping
    • Socially interactive – encourages engagement with other people
    • Joyful to experience – is pleasurable for the child

(Golinkoff; Kathy Hirsh-Pasek, PhD, Lefkowitz Faculty Fellow in Psychology at Temple University and Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution)

For more on selecting high quality content for children of different ages, check out our comprehensive age-based parenting guides:

Just because an app costs money doesn’t mean it’s a better app than a free one.

Roberta Golinkoff, PhD Unidel H. Rodney Sharp Chair and Professor, School of Education, University of Delaware